The Reluctant Hero: Characters Who Rise to the Occasion
In the vast landscape of literature, cinema, and folklore, there exists an enduring archetype—the reluctant hero.
This figure, emblematic of the human condition, is not born of royal lineage or trained for battle; rather, they are ordinary individuals thrust into extraordinary circumstances, compelled by fate or necessity to take up the mantle of heroism. From the humble hobbit Frodo Baggins to the wizarding world's Harry Potter, from the dystopian dystopia Katniss Everdeen to the gritty John McClane, the reluctant hero stands as a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the capacity for greatness within us all.
The journey of the reluctant hero is a narrative as ancient as storytelling itself—a saga of self-discovery, growth, and redemption. At the outset, they often stand at the precipice of their comfort zone, teetering on the edge of doubt, fear, and a profound sense of inadequacy. They may possess no special skills or talents, no grand destiny foretold by prophecy or lineage. Yet, when fate intervenes and circumstances demand action, they find within themselves the courage and determination to confront their fears and rise to the occasion.
Consider the saga of Bilbo Baggins, the unassuming hobbit thrust into the heart of Middle-earth's greatest conflict in J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit." At the outset of his adventure, Bilbo is content with the simple pleasures of his quiet life in the Shire, far removed from the perils of the wider world. Yet, when the wizard Gandalf and a band of dwarves come knocking at his door, seeking a burglar to aid them in reclaiming their homeland from the fearsome dragon Smaug, Bilbo finds himself swept up in a journey beyond his wildest imaginings.
Throughout his quest, Bilbo grapples with doubt and uncertainty, questioning his own worth and abilities at every turn. He faces trolls, goblins, and dragons, navigating treacherous landscapes and confronting his own inner demons. Yet, despite his initial reluctance, Bilbo discovers hidden reserves of courage and resourcefulness within himself, ultimately playing a pivotal role in the defeat of Smaug and the restoration of peace to the land.
Similarly, in Suzanne Collins' "The Hunger Games," we encounter Katniss Everdeen, a young woman thrust into a dystopian nightmare where survival is not guaranteed. Raised in poverty and deprivation in the oppressed nation of Panem, Katniss is no stranger to hardship. Yet, when her younger sister Prim is selected as a tribute in the annual Hunger Games—a televised fight to the death among children—Katniss volunteers to take her place, knowing full well the dangers that await her.
Throughout the Games, Katniss grapples with her own moral compass, torn between self-preservation and the desire to protect those she loves. She forms alliances, outwits her adversaries, and ultimately emerges victorious, sparking a rebellion against the oppressive regime of the Capitol. In doing so, Katniss transcends her status as a mere pawn in the Capitol's games, becoming a symbol of hope and defiance for oppressed people everywhere.
The journey of the reluctant hero is not without its challenges and sacrifices. Along the way, they may face doubt, despair, and moments of profound darkness. They may lose friends, allies, and even parts of themselves in the crucible of their trials. Yet, it is precisely through these hardships that the reluctant hero finds their true strength and resilience, forging a path of redemption and transformation.
In the end, the journey of the reluctant hero is a testament to the power of ordinary individuals to effect extraordinary change. It reminds us that heroism is not defined by grandiose acts of valour or feats of strength, but by the willingness to stand up in the face of adversity, to confront our fears, and to fight for what is right. Whether in the pages of a book, on the silver screen, or in the annals of history, the story of the reluctant hero resonates with us because it speaks to the fundamental truth of the human experience—that greatness lies within us all, waiting to be discovered.
Pros & Cons of the Reluctant Hero
Pros
1. Relatable: Reluctant heroes often struggle with self-doubt and uncertainty, making them highly relatable to audiences. Their journey of overcoming obstacles resonates with readers or viewers who may have faced similar challenges in their own lives.
2. Depth of Character Development: The reluctance of these heroes adds layers to their character development. As they grapple with their doubts and fears, they undergo significant growth and transformation throughout the narrative, providing rich storytelling opportunities.
3. Subversion of Tropes: Reluctant heroes subvert traditional hero tropes, offering a fresh perspective on the classic hero's journey. By defying expectations and embracing vulnerability, they challenge conventional notions of heroism and courage.
4. Moral Complexity: Reluctant heroes often wrestle with moral dilemmas and ethical choices, adding depth and complexity to their narratives. Their internal struggles with right and wrong make for compelling storytelling and invite audiences to ponder the complexities of human nature.
5. Realistic Representation: Reluctant heroes reflect the reality that not all individuals are born with innate heroism or bravery. Their initial reluctance to embrace their heroic role mirrors the hesitations and reservations that many people would feel when confronted with extraordinary circumstances, making their journey more believable and authentic.
Cons:
1. Initial Passivity: The reluctance of these heroes may lead to a slow start or a lack of immediate action in the narrative, potentially testing the patience of some audiences who prefer more action-oriented storytelling.
2. Predictability: The arc of the reluctant hero is a familiar trope in literature and media, which may lead to predictability in their character development and story progression. Audiences may anticipate the eventual transformation of the hero from reluctance to heroism, diminishing the element of surprise.
3. Overuse: The trope of the reluctant hero has been utilised extensively in various genres, leading to a sense of formulaic storytelling in some cases. Overuse of this archetype can result in clichés and stereotypes, reducing the impact of individual narratives.
4. Lack of Agency: Reluctant heroes may initially lack agency in their own stories, as they are often thrust into their heroic roles by external forces or circumstances beyond their control. This can diminish their sense of autonomy and proactive decision-making, potentially undermining their agency as protagonists.
5. Emotional Distance: Some audiences may find it difficult to fully connect with reluctant heroes who remain emotionally distant or closed off due to their internal struggles. The constant inner turmoil and hesitation of these characters may create a barrier to forming a deep emotional bond with them.
Pro Tips
1. Establish Clear Motivations: Ensure that the reluctance of your hero is grounded in believable motivations and internal conflicts. Explore their fears, doubts, and past experiences that contribute to their hesitance to embrace their heroic role. Providing depth to their character will make their journey more compelling and relatable to readers.
2. Show Incremental Growth: Chart the gradual evolution of your reluctant hero from a state of hesitation to one of empowerment. Instead of an abrupt transformation, depict small victories, setbacks, and moments of self-discovery that contribute to their growth over the course of the narrative. This incremental progression will make their eventual heroism feel earned and satisfying.
3. Balance Vulnerability with Strength: Strive to strike a balance between vulnerability and strength in your hero's characterisation. While their reluctance may stem from insecurities and weaknesses, showcase moments of resilience, bravery, and moral integrity that demonstrate their underlying heroism. This duality will create a multidimensional character with whom readers can empathise and root for.
4. Provide External Catalysts: Introduce external catalysts or mentors who challenge your hero's reluctance and catalyse their journey towards heroism. Whether it's a wise mentor figure, a compelling moral cause, or a personal connection to someone in need, external factors can push your hero out of their comfort zone and propel them towards action.
5. Offer Meaningful Choices: Present your reluctant hero with meaningful choices and moral dilemmas that force them to confront their fears and values. Allow them to grapple with the consequences of their decisions and the impact they have on themselves and others. By giving your hero agency in their own story, you empower them to actively shape their journey and define their path to heroism.
Til next time.
If you want to learn more about building a believable and immersive fantasy world and improving your writing, check out my other posts:
PS - Don’t forget to sign up below for updates on new book releases and blog articles. Also, drop by my Patreon and socials.