The Chosen One
In the vast realm of fantasy fiction, the Chosen One trope has long reigned supreme. The prophecy, the destined hero, the epic quest — these elements have become the cornerstone of many beloved tales. However, in an age where readers crave fresh narratives and unique perspectives, subverting the expectations tied to the Chosen One becomes a powerful tool for writers seeking to captivate audiences in new ways.
Understanding the Trope:
At its core, the Chosen One trope revolves around a central character, destined by fate or prophecy to save the world. This narrative formula, while time-tested and successful, risks becoming stale without innovation. Writers must delve into the roots of the trope, understanding its archetypal significance and the expectations it carries. Recognising the traditional elements — the prophecy, the call to adventure, the extraordinary abilities — lays the foundation for effective subversion.
Deconstructing Prophecy and Destiny:
To break free from the mould, authors can begin by deconstructing the very essence of prophecy and destiny. Challenge the notion that a single individual is preordained to save the world. Introduce doubt, ambiguity, and multiple interpretations of the prophecy. By doing so, writers inject a sense of unpredictability into the narrative, keeping readers on the edge of their seats as they question the true nature of the Chosen One.
Crafting Nuanced Characters:
One of the key aspects of subversion lies in crafting nuanced characters. Move beyond the stereotypical hero's journey and explore the complexities of your protagonist. Introduce flaws, fears, and personal struggles that go beyond the overarching destiny. By humanising the Chosen One, writers create characters with whom readers can empathise, fostering a deeper connection that transcends the traditional hero worship.
Redefining Extraordinary Abilities:
The Chosen One often possesses extraordinary abilities that set them apart. To subvert expectations, consider redefining what these abilities entail. Instead of the conventional superhuman strength or magical prowess, explore unconventional powers or curse-like burdens. Force the Chosen One to grapple with the consequences of their abilities, adding layers of moral ambiguity and ethical dilemmas that challenge the traditional hero narrative.
Embracing Diversity in Narratives:
Challenge the homogeneity often associated with Chosen One narratives by embracing diversity. Explore protagonists from different cultural backgrounds, genders, or identities. Subvert stereotypes associated with the hero archetype by showcasing a broader range of voices and perspectives. In doing so, writers contribute to a more inclusive and representative fantasy landscape.
Flipping the Mentor Archetype:
In many Chosen One tales, the mentor plays a crucial role in guiding the hero. Subvert this archetype by flipping the dynamics of mentorship. Introduce mentors who are flawed, conflicted, or even antagonistic. Force the Chosen One to navigate a web of conflicting advice and questionable guidance, adding layers of complexity to the mentor-mentee relationship.
Unpredictable Plot Twists:
Keep readers guessing by introducing unpredictable plot twists. Subvert the expected trajectory of the hero's journey. Perhaps the Chosen One fails in a critical moment, leading to unexpected consequences. Challenge the assumption that the hero always emerges victorious, creating a narrative that defies convention and embraces the uncertainties of storytelling.
Exploring Collaborative Narratives:
Move away from the solitary hero narrative by exploring collaborative storytelling. Introduce a group of characters, each contributing in unique ways to the overarching quest. Challenge the notion that the fate of the world rests solely on the shoulders of one individual. By fostering a sense of teamwork and camaraderie, writers create narratives that emphasise collective strength over individual heroics.
Shifting the Focus from External to Internal Conflict:
Traditional Chosen One narratives often emphasise external conflicts with a clear antagonist. Subvert this focus by shifting the narrative lens to internal conflicts. Explore the psychological toll of being the Chosen One, the self-doubt, and the internal struggles that arise. By delving into the hero's internal journey, writers add layers of depth that go beyond the external battles.
Episodic Storytelling and Unconventional Endings:
Consider adopting an episodic storytelling approach where the hero's journey unfolds in unexpected ways. Embrace unconventional endings that defy the typical hero's triumphant conclusion. Subvert the expectation that every story must end with the defeat of a great evil or the realisation of a grand prophecy. Allow for open-ended conclusions that leave room for interpretation and contemplation.
The Chosen One trope requires a delicate balance of understanding its conventions and strategically challenging them. By embracing innovation, diverse perspectives, and unexpected twists, writers can breathe new life into fantasy fiction, offering readers narratives that defy expectations and linger in the imagination long after the final page is turned.
Pros & Cons of Using the Chosen One Trope:
- Pro: The trope provides a central figure with a clear purpose, offering a straightforward narrative focus. This can guide readers through the story and create a strong, cohesive plot.
- Pro: The Chosen One often faces monumental challenges, adding an epic scale to the story. High stakes and world-altering events can captivate readers who enjoy grand, fantastical narratives.
- Pro: Prophecies and destinies bring inherent tension and suspense. Readers are compelled to follow the protagonist's journey, eagerly anticipating the fulfilment or subversion of the predicted outcomes.
- Pro: The Chosen One taps into mythical and symbolic archetypes, resonating with timeless themes. This can create a sense of familiarity and depth, connecting the story to broader cultural and literary traditions.
- Pro: Readers often find empowerment and escapism in stories where a seemingly ordinary individual discovers extraordinary abilities or a unique destiny. This can create a fulfilling and inspiring reading experience.
- Con: The Chosen One trope, if not handled with innovation, can lead to predictability and clichés. Readers may anticipate story beats and character arcs, potentially diminishing the element of surprise.
- Con: Relying solely on the Chosen One premise may result in underdeveloped characters. If the protagonist's identity is defined solely by their destined role, it can overshadow nuanced character development.
- Con: The Chosen One trope is prevalent in fantasy literature. Overuse across various media can lead to fatigue among readers who seek more original and inventive storytelling approaches.
- Con: Some iterations of the Chosen One may face accusations of lacking agency. If the protagonist's choices are primarily driven by destiny, it can diminish the impact of personal agency and decision-making.
- Con: Subverting the Chosen One trope requires a delicate balance. Writers aiming to defy expectations must navigate the challenge of providing a fresh perspective without losing the essence of the chosen narrative structure.
Pro Tips when using the Chosen One Trope:
1. Add Layers to Characterisation:
- Tip: Infuse your Chosen One with multidimensional traits and flaws. Avoid reducing their identity solely to their destined role. Explore their personal struggles, fears, and growth, creating a well-rounded character that extends beyond their chosen status.
2. Challenge Conventional Tropes:
- Tip: Embrace opportunities to subvert expectations within the Chosen One narrative. Challenge traditional hero tropes by introducing unexpected twists, moral ambiguity, or unconventional character arcs. Surprise your readers and keep the story unpredictable.
3. Diversify Cultural Influences:
- Tip: Broaden the cultural influences shaping your Chosen One narrative. Explore mythologies and folklore beyond the well-trodden paths of Western traditions. Infuse your story with diverse cultural elements, enriching the narrative tapestry and offering fresh perspectives.
4. Focus on Relationships and Dynamics:
- Tip: Center your story on relationships and character dynamics. Whether it's the Chosen One's connections with allies, mentors, or adversaries, interpersonal relationships add depth to the narrative. Highlight how these dynamics shape the protagonist's journey.
5. Build a Rich, Evocative World:
- Tip: Elevate your world-building beyond generic fantasy settings. Craft a rich, evocative world with its own history, cultures, and conflicts. The backdrop should be more than a stage for the Chosen One's journey; it should be an integral part of the story, influencing events and characters.
In conclusion, the Chosen One trope, when approached with innovation and creativity, can be a springboard for crafting unforgettable stories. By subverting expectations, crafting unique protagonists, and embracing the nuances of character development and world-building, authors can breathe new life into the fantasy genre. In an era where readers crave originality, the power to captivate lies in the hands of those who dare to break the mould, drawing inspiration from the rich tapestry of folklore and myth.
Til next time.
If you want to learn more about building a believable and immersive fantasy world and improving your writing, check out my other posts:
PS - Don’t forget to sign up below for updates on new book releases and blog articles. Also, drop by my Patreon and socials.