Why We Crave Black and White Morality in Fantasy
Have you ever pondered the magnetic allure of clear-cut good and evil in fantasy narratives?
This dichotomy isn’t merely a narrative convenience; it taps into fundamental psychological needs and cultural archetypes that resonate deeply within us. In this exploration, I’ll dissect the reasons behind our fascination with black and white morality and examine how these stark distinctions shape our engagement with fantasy realms.
The Allure of Clear Morality
Simplicity Amid Complexity
In this convoluted world, we seek clarity. Black and white morality offers a framework that delineates heroism from villainy with unambiguous precision. This simplicity not only renders narratives accessible but also provides a sense of order in a chaotic landscape.
Consider the classic epic of The Lord of the Rings. Characters like Frodo and Aragorn epitomise unwavering goodness, while Sauron embodies unadulterated evil. This clear dichotomy heightens the stakes of their journey, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the narrative's emotional impact.
Moral Certainty and Identity
Psychologist Jonathan Haidt elucidates that morality is intrinsically linked to our identities. When we engage with stories featuring well-defined moral lines, we can easily affirm our own values and beliefs against the backdrop of the narrative. These tales serve as moral compasses, reinforcing our understanding of right and wrong.
In The Lion King, Simba's journey is framed as a struggle between light and darkness. Scar represents treachery and deceit, while Mufasa and the Circle of Life symbolise integrity and duty. This clarity allows audiences to comprehend and empathise with Simba's growth and moral awakening.
Psychological Underpinnings of Black and White Morality
Cognitive Ease
Humans are inherently cognitive misers; we prefer information that demands minimal mental effort. Stories that present clear moral distinctions facilitate cognitive ease, allowing readers to engage without grappling with ambiguous ethical dilemmas.
Research published in the journal Psychological Science indicates that narratives with distinct moral choices are more enjoyable for audiences, fostering a deeper emotional investment in the story.
The Hero's Journey and Archetypes
Joseph Campbell’s concept of the Hero’s Journey underscores the significance of archetypal characters who embody good and evil. These archetypes create a familiar narrative structure that resonates with audiences. The clarity of these roles enhances the story’s impact and invokes universal themes of conflict, courage, and resolution.
In Harry Potter, the stark contrast between Harry and Voldemort serves as a quintessential representation of this dichotomy. Harry symbolises hope and bravery, while Voldemort embodies fear and tyranny. The clarity of their roles amplifies the emotional stakes, making their conflict deeply engaging.
The Role of Cultural Narratives
Collective Morality in Storytelling
Historically, cultures have employed storytelling as a vehicle for imparting moral lessons. Clear distinctions between good and evil reinforce societal norms and values, allowing individuals to grapple with their own moral compasses through the lens of narrative.
The Star Wars saga epitomises this struggle between light and dark. The conflict between the Jedi and the Sith serves as a powerful allegory for the battle between good and evil, resonating universally across cultures and illustrating our inherent desire for clarity in moral judgment.
Nostalgia and Familiarity
Nostalgia plays a significant role in our attraction to black and white morality. Many of us were raised on stories that featured unambiguous moral landscapes, creating lasting impressions that shape our engagement with narratives today. This sense of nostalgia compels us to seek out similar stories, reinforcing our emotional connection.
Classic fairy tales and mythology, deliver straightforward moral lessons that linger long after the final page is turned. The easily identifiable villains provide satisfying resolutions that align with our expectations of justice, enhancing the overall experience.
Conclusion
Our fascination with black and white morality in fantasy fiction speaks to our deep-rooted psychological needs for simplicity, identity, and moral clarity.
These narratives not only entertain us but also offer profound insights into our own values and beliefs. This world is complex and chaotic and the allure of clear distinctions between good and evil remains a compelling force in storytelling.
Next time you immerse yourself in a fantasy novel or cinematic masterpiece, take a moment to appreciate the intricate psychological and cultural layers at play. The heroes and villains may reside in fantastical realms, but the truths they unveil about our own moral landscapes are undeniably real.
Here are five pro tips to consider when writing stories with clear good and evil:
1. Establish Strong Archetypes
Create well-defined characters that embody classic archetypes of good and evil. This clarity helps readers instantly understand the stakes and motivations behind each character, making the narrative more engaging.
2. Craft Compelling Conflicts
Ensure that the central conflict between good and evil is both relatable and emotionally charged. The more personal and high-stakes the conflict, the more invested readers will become in the outcome.
3. Maintain Consistent Moral Codes
Keep your characters’ moral codes consistent throughout the story. Even in a world of black and white morality, characters can evolve, but their fundamental beliefs should remain intact to avoid confusing the reader.
4. Utilise Symbolism and Themes
Employ symbols and recurring themes to reinforce the moral distinctions in your narrative. This can enhance the depth of your story and provide readers with a richer understanding of the moral landscape.
5. Provide Nuance in Villainy
While maintaining clear good and evil roles, consider adding layers to your villains. A compelling antagonist can have understandable motivations, allowing readers to see the complexity behind their actions without blurring the moral lines too much.
Til next time.
If you want to learn more about building a believable and immersive fantasy world and improving your writing, check out my other posts:
PS - Don’t forget to sign up below for updates on new book releases and blog articles. Also, drop by my Patreon and socials.